The One Piece saga is reaching its climactic stages, and one of the most anticipated battles fans speculate about is Monkey D. Luffy vs. Fleet Admiral Akainu (Sakazuki). Given their history at Marineford, where Akainu killed Luffy’s brother Portgas D. Ace and severely injured Luffy, the prospect of their rematch has fueled endless debates. However, others argue that Sabo, the current Flame Emperor and Luffy’s other sworn brother, is more thematically suited to face Akainu.
This article explores the likelihood of a Luffy vs. Akainu showdown, the narrative justifications, and possible alternatives.
1. Why Luffy vs. Akainu Makes Sense
1.1 Akainu is One of Luffy’s Most Personal Enemies
Akainu’s Magu Magu no Mi (Magma Fruit) was responsible for Ace’s death, a tragedy that deeply scarred Luffy. Not only that, but Akainu also inflicted a severe chest scar on Luffy while he was unconscious. Since then, Akainu has remained a symbol of Marine tyranny, representing absolute justice and ruthlessness.
Whitebeard’s prophecy at Marineford stated that those who seek the One Piece will bring about a great war. If Luffy declares war on the World Government after discovering the Void Century’s secrets, Akainu, as the Fleet Admiral, would naturally stand as the Marines’ strongest defender.
1.2 Narrative Parallels Between Roger vs. Garp and Luffy vs. Akainu
Historically, the Pirate King Gol D. Roger had Monkey D. Garp as his primary Marine rival. Luffy, aspiring to be the next Pirate King, will need a Marine counterpart—Akainu fits this role. While Koby or Smoker could play a similar role, neither possesses Akainu’s rank, power, or thematic importance.
1.3 Luffy’s Growth and Akainu’s Strength
Luffy has achieved Gear 5 and awakened the true power of the Nika Fruit, making him one of the strongest in the world. Meanwhile, Akainu remains an Admiral-level threat, possessing Advanced Armament and Observation Haki, along with a Logia Devil Fruit that is arguably one of the most destructive in the series.
If Luffy vs. Akainu happens, the fight will likely be one of the most brutal and emotionally charged battles in One Piece.
2. Why Sabo vs. Akainu Makes Sense Instead
2.1 Sabo’s Guilt Over Ace’s Death
Sabo was absent during Marineford, only learning about Ace’s death after the war. Since then, he has inherited Ace’s will and Flame-Flame Fruit (Mera Mera no Mi). A fight between Akainu and Sabo would be like Ace himself coming back to get revenge.
Moreover, Sabo and Akainu are thematically opposed:
- Sabo fights for freedom (Revolutionary Army)
- Akainu fights for absolute justice (World Government)
Since the Revolutionary Army is actively warring against the World Government, Sabo vs. Akainu could be more logical than Luffy taking on the Fleet Admiral.
2.2 Who is Luffy’s "Final Opponent" Instead?
If Luffy doesn’t fight Akainu, his ultimate opponent could be:
- Imu, the mysterious sovereign of the World Government
- Blackbeard, his greatest pirate rival
- The Gorosei, the true power behind the World Government
If Oda decides that Luffy’s fight against the system itself is more important, then Sabo might get the honor of taking down Akainu.
3. Could Both Battles Happen?
It’s also possible that both Sabo vs. Akainu and Luffy vs. Akainu occur. This could unfold in a couple of ways:
- Sabo fights Akainu first, but loses, setting up Luffy to defeat him in revenge.
- Sabo and Luffy team up to defeat Akainu, mirroring Luffy and Ace’s brotherly bond.
- Luffy and Akainu clash briefly, but the main fight goes to Sabo, allowing him to avenge Ace.
The exact scenario will depend on how Oda wants to conclude the Final War.
4. Who Wins in a Fight: Luffy or Akainu?
4.1 Akainu’s Strengths
- Magma is hotter than fire → Akainu’s Magu Magu no Mi completely overpowered Ace’s Mera Mera no Mi.
- Incredible endurance → Akainu survived attacks from Whitebeard.
- Logia + Advanced Haki → He is a master of Armament Haki, making his attacks physically devastating.
4.2 Luffy’s Strengths
- Gear 5 Awakening → Luffy’s Sun God Nika form gives him toon-force reality-warping abilities.
- Conqueror’s Haki Coating → Luffy can damage even Kaido, one of the strongest beings in One Piece.
- Immunity to fire? → Given his rubbery nature and Gear 5’s cartoon physics, Luffy may resist Akainu’s magma.
Right now, Luffy seems stronger than Akainu, but a direct fight would still be brutal.
5. Conclusion: Will Luffy vs. Akainu Happen?
There are two main possibilities:
-
Luffy vs. Akainu is inevitable
- Luffy is the protagonist and has a direct emotional and narrative reason to fight Akainu.
- Akainu is the strongest Marine and will likely stand in the way of the Pirate King.
- Luffy’s revenge for Ace is still an unresolved plotline.
-
Sabo vs. Akainu is the better match-up
- Sabo has the Flame-Flame Fruit, making it a rematch of Ace vs. Akainu.
- The Revolutionary Army is a better enemy for Akainu than the Straw Hats.
- Luffy’s final opponent might be someone beyond Akainu (Imu, Blackbeard, or the Gorosei).
Which Scenario is More Likely?
- If Oda wants to conclude the Marineford arc’s consequences, then Luffy will fight Akainu.
- If Oda prioritizes Revolutionary vs. Government themes, then Sabo will take Akainu instead.
- If both happen, Sabo might weaken Akainu, and Luffy finishes him off.
No matter which path Oda chooses, One Piece fans can expect an epic battle between these powerful characters.
What do you think? Will Luffy face Akainu, or will Sabo take his place? Let me know in the comments!
Follow on Twitter